Jonah Goldberg:
Well, you may have heard that I got into an online spat with the folks at The Bulwark. For some fans of both publications, this felt like a tragic family squabble. For many progressives it was bizarre, akin to the People’s Front of Judea vs. the Judean People’s Front. That’s the thing about the tyranny of small differences: They aren’t small differences to the people on the inside of the conflict.
What started it was a video of Bulwark publisher Sarah Longwell at a Democratic Party conference in Colorado. She told the assembled Democrats, “You may know us, we’re the Never Trumpers. At least we were 10 years ago. Now we’re just kind of libs just like the rest of you.”
In response to the furor, Longwell tried to claim that she meant “classically liberal.” I think this was preposterous on its face. No one in that room heard that and said to themselves, “Oh, she must mean like Lord Acton or Ludwig von Mises.” And Longwell certainly didn’t think the room full of Democratic partisans was a meeting of the Mont Pelerin Society. It was spin, not an argument.
For a great many people, Longwell’s statement and her effort at damage control confirmed a widely held perspective that The Bulwark, which was founded in 2018 on the slogan that it was dedicated to “conserving conservatism,” had become more of a Democratic-aligned outlet than a, well, bulwark of conservatism.
You can read the whole thing here, but you really don’t need to. I just want to say that even I don’t believe that Goldberg believes more than half of what he’s saying — he is being way too generous and nice here.
I’ve been a Dispatch member basically since their inception. (I’m bummed I didn’t join as lifetime premium member or whatever they call it, back when I had extra money lying around.) I like The Dispatch. I think they are a great conservative magazine. There are, of course, some exceptions in their oeuvre, but after nearly the entire right-wing information ecosystem went prone, they basically took what had been good about it and made it better. More people should read them.
Now… I gave The Bulwark a fair shake a few years ago. I cannot overemphasize how vacuous and hollow I found them to be. Anyone who thinks that The Bulwark has had good conservative roots needs a family intervention. I mean this when I say it: I would sooner join the Democratic Party — like, blue-pilled join — than follow the Bulwark nihilists anywhere. Say what you want about the Democrats, but at least there’s some ethos.
But that last comment starts to undermine the moral. The ultimate point here is that character is destiny, the method is the madness. There isn’t one way you do politics and another thing that you are. I accept that life can force exceptions, but those two things cannot remain apart for long. And in my estimation, The Bulwark kept them apart for precisely 3 seconds, if that.
As Goldberg puts it,
these warring factions share what Whittaker Chambers described as the “Popular Front mind.” Victory over the hated enemy is self-justifying. All other concerns are subordinated to the need to defeat the opposing tribe. As George Orwell put it, this mentality can lead to the view that “There is no crime, absolutely none, that cannot be condoned when ‘our’ side commits it.” In fairness to The Bulwark, I don’t think that is an accurate depiction of its approach or mindset. But the agonizing over Graham Platner, support for Abdul El-Sayed, etc., point more in that direction than I think they sometimes realize.
Longwell is very honest that this is her point of view. “Guys, I put all my policy preferences aside,” she recently said on a podcast. “I subvert my policy preferences in favor of how do we save America from what’s happening right now? And I think that should be the baseline of everybody who wants to be in the tent.” I assume she meant “subordinate” instead of “subvert,” but subvert does seem a bit like a Freudian slip. […]
The anti-anti frame starts from the premise that if you aren’t fully on board in the fight against the enemy, you must not really be against the enemy or not see the enemy for what it is. This mindset flattens everything down to the political struggle of the moment, driving one to both “subvert” and subordinate one’s long-held views for the cause, and reifies disagreement into some manufactured ideological stance. […]
When I sit down at the computer, I ask myself, “What do I think about this?” or “What would be interesting or fun to write about?” The notion that I would do otherwise is something that a partisan or political operative might think. But I am neither. I don’t think like one and I don’t want to be one. […]
When I said that Always Trump and Never Trump are two sides of the same coin, I didn’t mean that Trump’s corruption and assaults on democracy are as bad as what the Democrats or The Bulwark are doing or supporting. I meant—and mean—that Popular Frontism is a one-dimensional way of thinking about politics. Hyperpartisans think that way. There’s a role for hyperpartisans and political operators in a democracy. But it’s not my role (and not the role of The Dispatch). After a decade of refusing to act like I work for the Republican National Committee, I’ll be damned if I’m going to act like I work for the Democratic National Committee. Subordinating or subverting your beliefs to get the election returns you want is not my job.
A tragic family squabble? No. This was always where any relationship between these two publications was going to end up.