the bread and the sentence, the office and the whip

Omar Mohammed:

People call them monsters. I will not. A monster is a creature without choice. To call these men and women monsters is to say they could not help what they did. That is a lie, and the lie serves them, because it removes the thing that makes their acts punishable: the choice.

I compiled intelligence files on thirty-eight of them. I will not publish their names. But I will describe how they lived inside the city they governed—because the living is where the truth sits. The killing is what the world already knows. The living is what the world refuses to see.

The shift change happened on Thursdays and Tuesdays. Each fighter received leave every fifteen days. Those who worked in the judiciary, the education bureau, and the real estate office kept regular hours. They ate at the restaurants on hagata Street—the cultural district, the street where the bookshops had been. The foreign fighters—Chechens, Tunisians, men from the Gulf—treated the restaurants as though they were on holiday. They had moved into the furnished houses of families given seventy-two hours to leave with nothing. A German fighter married a local girl and was living in the Andalus neighborhood, in a home of displaced Christians. He cooked in a kitchen that still smelled of the spices the Christian woman had stored in jars she had labeled in Syriac.

I knew one of them. Two doors from a friend’s house. He had been a taxi driver before the fall. After the fall, he appeared in uniform. He was responsible for interrogation. We still sat together sometimes in the evenings. He told me about the women they had killed. He used the word “cleaned.” Then he asked whether I had eaten, and whether my mother was well.

A livestock trader—forty-eight years old, two wives, nine children—was appointed judge in the Sharia court, sentencing former police officers to death. The distance between the courthouse where he sentenced men and the bakery where he bought bread for his children was four minutes by car.

A petty criminal—illiterate, accusations of violence—joined the intelligence service. He was given a weapon, a salary, and the authority to arrest and kill. The authority came with a title. The title came with a department. The department came with a filing system. The filing system made him legitimate. The machine did not ask who you had been. It asked who you were willing to become.

The Education Bureau was rewriting the curricula inside the central library of Mosul University—-headed by a German citizen of Egyptian origin from the al-Zarqawi network, a man known as Dhul-Qarnayn. By February 2015, the campus had become a military installation—residence halls housing fighters, laboratories converted to weapons workshops. The Sudair tourist village on the outskirts, where families had picnicked, became a training camp. The buildings were the same. The forest was the same. The picnic tables were still there. The weapons were new.

That distance—four minutes, the same afternoon, the same man—is what the word “monster” conceals. Monsters do not buy bread. Monsters do not ask about school. These men did all of those things, on the same days, with the same hands.

I do not hate them. Hatred requires a reduction of the other person to a category, and the work I did for eighteen months was the refusal to reduce anything to a category. I documented them with the precision of a man who understood that the record is the only thing that survives the regime that produced it. Accuracy requires seeing them as what they were—the taxi drivers and seminary students and livestock traders and petty criminals who made choices, who had full control of their actions, who bought bread on the way home from the courthouse, and who will one day answer for what they did between the bread and the sentence.

[…]

One of these organizational charts was designed against a background of flowers. Pink and white blossoms, green grass, blue sky. Someone in the Islamic Police’s administrative office had chosen this template. Someone had selected the flowers. The same department that processed flogging sentences and tracked executions had decorated its personnel chart with wildflowers. I do not know what to do with that detail except to record it. The flowers are the thesis of this chapter compressed into a single image: the office and the whip, together, in the same document, produced by the same hand. The flowers and the death sentences. The blue sky and the inventory of weapons.

[…]

Not masked men in the desert. An office. Using the vocabulary of God. Staffed by the neighbors. Decorated with flowers. Stamped in blue ink on lined paper.

you somehow

A mixed feelings post from two weeks ago that I wasn’t sure was worth the time. But whatever. I added a little memory to it and here it is.


“In case you somehow missed it…”

Thusly O. Alan Noble starts his piece on the Christianity Today (CT) kerfuffle that Ruth Graham reported on last week and that Bonnie Kristian, former deputy editor of CT, also wrote about.

I want to talk about those two little words, “you somehow.”

I am not as well-read as my reputation often suggests. Not even close, I would argue. For one thing, I am a slow reader; I can read at about the pace that I talk, and often read slower than that. And most the people who I read make me feel like I don’t read or have not read much at all, because, compared to them, I haven’t and don’t.

That said, I do read about… 100x more than almost everyone else I know. That’s probably not an exaggeration, and I’m not boasting. Quite the opposite: I kind of don’t like how much time I spend reading — how much time I waste reading — which really is, quite literally, abnormal. And again, I am a slooow readeeer.

But I do know that I read a lot more than the average person.

I say all that only to say this: I “somehow” missed it. I’m a NYT subscriber, I even follow Ruth Graham regularly, and Bonnie Kristian’s newsletter shows up in my inbox every week. And still I somehow missed it.

And if I missed it, it’s a safe bet — I’ve thrown a couple feelers out to confirm, but it’s still a bet — that no one I know knows about it. Nor — with due respect to those whose jobs and lives are directly affected — would any of them care about it.

I don’t do this that much, but I do it often enough to be a little self-conscious about it. To be honest, I don’t like using phrases like “everyone I know,” etc. But part of what I’m “about” in this here blogosphere is exactly that funny gap found in that opening line — the gap between words that get passed around between The People Who Pass Around Words and the average person who never reads them.

And so, this morning I found myself sitting by the wood fire, drinking coffee and once again asking, with this reverberating existential chuckle, Who are you guys writing for? Who do any of you think you are writing for?

I hope it doesn’t sound like I’m taking one little line too seriously. (Or one word, really: “in case you missed it” is a very different thing from “in case you somehow missed it.”) It’s possible to read that opening line very lightly, even with a little humor. It’s possible, too, that if you were reading Noble’s piece then there really is a better chance that you would already have been in the know. But in my stubborn and biased little world, I read it as a hint, and a remarkably relevant one.

While I am certainly being cynically critical here, I’m also genuinely trying to figure this out. When Noble and Kristian say we need “institutions” like CT, I want to trust them. But that’s a difficult trust to put shape to: I have spent 40 years living in and among deeply evangelical circles and I do not exaggerate when I say that I don’t know one person who reads Christianity Today. I would struggle to find even one person who has ever subscribed to them.

The best that I can say — and I do largely believe this — is that the function of an institution like CT (if it is, in fact, right to call it an institution; I’m not certain about that) is nonetheless significant regardless of my own ability to trace it. I can and should attempt to grant that.

One can imagine wonderful ways that thoughtful if little-known publishing, no matter how “big” the name, could contribute to a bigger picture, or, as Noble says, how an institutional platform like CT could serve as “an incubator for evangelical writers, thinkers, and ideas.” At the same time, if a magazine read by very few outside the publishing industry simply disappeared, one can imagine all the energy, money, and time that went into it rather naturally redirecting itself, hopefully to a place with both institutional and grass roots.

But no matter how much I want to trust the hoped-for role of a magazine like CT, the problem still remains (as the ongoing administrative/editorial shakeup shakeup itself seems to indicate, though nothing I’m saying here is dependent on their current troubles.) Noble says we need them, and maybe that’s true. But need is a strong word. I think we should want magazines like CT, and we can benefit greatly from them. What we do need, however, are better conversations about who institutions or magazines like CT are for at all.

Let me attempt to get at something in the background here, something far more significant than one casual blogger being petty about an opening line.

I recall the lead-up to the 2016 election. The major leadership among (mostly white*) evangelicals seemed, by my reading, consistently opposed to the notion that faithful Christian witness could coexist with support for Mr. Trump.

“I will vote — but not for either of these two wicked candidates,” preached John Piper.

“To be a faithful Christian and American, I’m going to find myself unable to vote for either of those two choices from the major political parties,” said Al Mohler, to applause in whatever room he was in, I might add.**

Most leaders were not necessarily that blunt, but by and large they agreed: better to lose an election than to lose your soul.

I think everyone knew or suspected that support for Trump among evangelicals was a gigantic elephant in the room — an elephant in the room that was about to start walking around get the zoomies. (Possibly a few felt the need to be so blunt because they saw this antsy elephant.) Still, generally speaking, the expectation was that Hillary Clinton would win; the vibe from those with a public, published voice was that we were ready to move on, shake it off, and get back to the roots of Christian witness.

Then it happened — the thing that evangelicals chose and that they have yet to, and may never, recover from.

“In light of this stunning outcome,” wrote Collin Hansen at The Gospel Coalition the day after the election,

we must admit the obvious division between many evangelical leaders, elected and self-appointed, and the rest of the movement. At some point in the primary I realized that whatever I might say about my concerns with Trump, most American evangelicals weren’t listening. The same was even true with much more popular, trusted, and wise thinkers.

Reeling from the results of that insane election, Hansen had a question that badly needed asking, and he asked it bluntly: “Who exactly, are we ‘leaders’ claiming to lead?”

Hansen is editor in chief at The Gospel Coalition and former associate editor at (you guessed it) Christianity Today.

I have never since that time had the impression that they had or even could answer that question.***

I haven’t grabbed it, but it’s possible that at some point I’ll read Bonnie Kristian’s book In Defense of Evangelicals. Though she’s been in the subscription inbox for some time, I don’t know Kristian’s writing very well. My sense is that she’s quite solid. And I’m remarkably happy that Alan Jacobs, who I’ve read a lot of, provides the foreword and praise for her book. Happier I could not be to see these two fine people going to bat for evangelicals. As a disgruntled but still deeply Christian “exvangelical” Gonzo, I have my doubts about the effectiveness. I have pretty clear memories of Sunday lunch conversations and my own evolution away from the merit of “evangelicalism,” or even of the word “evangelical” itself. But I maintain a fondness for that world and for those people that the criticism cannot contain or extinguish.

A lot of different things are true here at the same time!

____

*At the time, I took Thabiti Anyabwile as representative of the non-white evangelical vote: “Between Clinton and Trump, I’m voting Clinton. I’ll go back to not voting when this man is defeated!” Or: “Donald Trump is destroying a party and a church in one candidacy,” he wrote in July 2016. “Next: the entire country.”

I can’t be sure, but as far as I can tell, the pieces that Anyabwile wrote going into that election have been scrubbed from the Gospel Coalition website. Here’s an excerpt from one that previously appeared on the site on June 7, 2016:

Here’s the problem with living 50 years after the American Civil Rights Movement and the de jure segregation of the land that produced it: Too many people now have no idea how every-day-horrendous-and-perilous life was under that system. And if you can’t imagine the daily stresses and sudden endangerment faced by African Americans in that system, then chances are you can’t quite fathom the alarm that survivors or students of that period have when we look at a Mr. Trump. And failing to recognize these things, you may be vulnerable to sliding over to the Trump column without due consideration of the ugliness of racism.

**I’ve mentioned Al Mohler before. On the way to the 2016 election, few evangelical leaders, it seemed to me, were more straightforward and vocal about Christians, as he put it, “supporting the insupportable and defending the in defensible” by voting for Trump. But Mohler quickly went on to set a very bad example for the kids. In fact, few evangelical leaders, it seems to me, have more blatantly and vocally turned hypocritical tail. If CT does get right-wing TikTokified, I think he’ll fit right in.

***I’m refraining from the use of language, but there’s a good phrase that describes this “something is deeply wrong” shock and the subsequent condition we have.

our common, everyday threat to the world

Abraham Joshua Heschel:

What manner of man is the prophet? A student of philosophy who turns from the discourses of the great metaphysicians to the orations of the prophets may feel as if he were going from the realm of the sublime to an area of trivialities. Instead of dealing with the timeless issues of being and becoming, of matter and form, of definitions and demonstrations, he is thrown into orations about widows and orphans, about the corruption of judges and affairs of the market place. Instead of showing us a way through the elegant mansions of the mind, the prophets take us to the slums. The world is a proud place, full of beauty, but the prophets are scandalized, and rave as if the whole world were a slum. They make much ado about paltry things, lavishing excessive language upon trifling subjects. What if somewhere in ancient Palestine poor people have not been treated properly by the rich? So what if some old women found pleasure and edification in worshiping “the Queen of Heaven”? Why such immoderate excitement? Why such intense indignation?

The things that horrified the prophets are even now daily occurrences all over the world. There is no society to which Amos’ words would not apply.

Hear this, you who trample upon the needy,
And bring the poor of the land to an end,
Saying: When will the new moon be over
That we may sell grain?
And the Sabbath,
That we may offer wheat for sale,
That we may make the ephah small and the shekel great,
And deal deceitfully with false balances,
That we may buy the poor for silver,
And the needy for a pair of sandals,
And sell the refuse of the wheat?

Amos 8:4–6

Indeed, the sort of crimes and even the amount of delinquency that fill the prophets of Israel with dismay do not go beyond that which we regard as normal, as typical ingredients of social dynamics. To us a single act of injustice—cheating in business, exploitation of the poor—is slight; to the prophets, a disaster. To us injustice is injurious to the welfare of the people; to the prophets it is a deathblow to existence; to us, an episode; to them, a catastrophe, a threat to the world.

the prophets endure

Abraham Joshua Heschel:

Indeed, it requires much effort to learn which questions should not be asked and which claims must not be entertained. What impairs our sight are habits of seeing as well as the mental concomitants of seeing. Our sight is suffused with knowing, instead of feeling painfully the lack of knowing what we see. The principle to be kept in mind is to know what we see rather than to see what we know.

Rather than blame things for being obscure, we should blame ourselves for being biased and prisoners of self-induced repetitiveness. […]

The situation of a person immersed in the prophets’ words is one of being exposed to a ceaseless shattering of indifference, and one needs a skull of stone to remain callous to such blows. I cannot remain indifferent to the question whether a decision I reach may prove fatal to my existence—whether to inhale the next breath in order to survive. Perhaps this is the issue that frightens the prophets. A people may be dying without being aware of it; a people may be able to survive, yet refuse to make use of their ability. […]

The prophets do not offer reflections about ideas in general. Their words are onslaughts, scuttling illusions of false security, challenging evasions, calling faith to account, questioning prudence and impartiality. […]

I was slowly led to the realization that some of the terms, motivations, and concerns which dominate our thinking may prove destructive of the roots of human responsibility and treasonable to the ultimate ground of human solidarity. The challenge we are all exposed to, and the dreadful shame that shatters our capacity for inner peace, defy the ways and patterns of our thinking. One is forced to admit that some of the causes and motives of our thinking have led our existence astray, that speculative prosperity is no answer to spiritual bankruptcy.

[…]

The prophet was an individual who said No to his society, condemning its habits and assumptions, its complacency, waywardness, and syncretism. He was often compelled to proclaim the very opposite of what his heart expected. His fundamental objective was to reconcile man and God. Why do the two need reconciliation? Perhaps it is due to man’s false sense of sovereignty, to his abuse of freedom, to his aggressive, sprawling pride, resenting God’s involvement in history.

Prophecy ceased; the prophets endure and can only be ignored at the risk of our own despair. It is for us to decide whether freedom is self-assertion or response to a demand; whether the ultimate situation is conflict or concern.

I suppose it’s worth mentioning that that last reference is, I believe, to Paul Tillich’s “religion as ‘ultimate concern.’

the smell of bread and the shape of what can’t be said

Omar Mohammed:

At the bakery near Forest Street—a tree-lined promenade that ran beside the Tigris in eastern Mosul—I had claimed to work. I did not bake. The owner was a man I paid for the arrangement—not a friend, not a relative, a man I had known before the fall [of the city to ISIS] who was willing to accept the risk for money. The bakery was a small space, low-ceilinged, with a clay oven set into the wall and flour dust on every surface that light could reach. People entered, waited, spoke to each other and to whoever stood behind the counter while the bread was prepared. The conversations were not directed at me. They were the ordinary speech of a neighborhood conducting its morning business complaints about prices, questions about which streets were passable, the particular silence that fell over the room whenever a man in ISIS dress walked past the open doorway. What I heard was not intelligence in the formal sense. It was the sound of a city thinking aloud in the one register it still trusted: the brief, careful, elliptical speech of people buying bread from a man they recognized. 

[…]

The bread came out in the early heat. The smell of it—the yeast, the char from the oven’s lip, the particular warmth of flour and water transformed—filled the small space and drifted into the street. People entered that smell and relaxed inside it, because bread is older than any regime and the body responds to it before the mind can intervene. That is what [gathering] intelligence looked like at the bakery: not a secret passed in a whisper, but the shape of what people could not say pressing against the shape of what they did say. The smell of bread was the last neutral thing in the city.

rendered dubious

Matthew Crawford:

Nest is a company that makes a “smart” thermostat for your home. It was incubated at Google and is owned by Google’s parent company, Alphabet. Legal scholars who analyzed everything you agree to when you use the Nest thermostat and its ecosystem of apps and devices concluded that, to do so knowingly, you would need to review nearly a thousand separate contracts” (Noto La Diega and Walden 2016). Of course, few people read even one such contract; perhaps Nest is counting on that. This degree of “asymmetry of information” renders the very idea of contract dubious. Whatever we want to call the relationship that obtains between Nest and its customers subjects, it is not one of market exchange in the usual sense.

[…]

The business rationale for the smart home is to bring the intimate patterns of domestic life into the fold of the surveillance economy, which has a one-way mirror quality. Increasingly, every aspect of our lives—including, for example, the emotional register of our voices and facial expressions during a Zoom call—are laid bare as a data to be collected by companies that, for their own part, guard with military-grade secrecy the algorithms by which they use this information to determine the world that is presented to us, including our news feeds (Asher-Schapiro 2022; Pasquale 2015). These companies are also in a position to determine our standing in the reputational economy. The credit rating agencies and insurance companies would like to know us more intimately; I suppose Alexa can help with that.

I haven’t read the other two post in this series, but here Crawford is rehashing things that have long been known. Take this as another example:

Google, Meta, X, Amazon, and Tik-Tok have established portals that people feel they have to pass through to conduct the business of life, to stay in touch with friends, or to participate in the public square. Such bottlenecks are a consequence of “the network effect,” which naturally tends toward oligopoly because the value of a network to those who use it increases as more people use it. Early innovations allowed these firms to take up their positions. It is not innovation, however, but instead their established positions and the ongoing control of the data it allows them to gather that account for the unprecedented rents these companies are able to collect. If those profits measure anything at all, it is the reach of a grid of surveillance that continues to metastasize.

It is not innovation. Putting aside the fact that Google is only ever “successful” by means of its purchasing power, this brings to mind Cal Newport’s 2016 Ted Talk and his defense against accusations of Luddism for rejecting social media: social media platforms are not a technology. They are (spying, manipulating, evil) forms of entertainment that harness technology, but that is all they are.

There are many good reasons to reject actual forms of technology, but you can say no to the Google-Meta-X-Amazon-Tik-Tok shit storm without in any way rejecting a single technology.

Again, this is getting to be old, old news. In fact, I don’t see anything significant here that isn’t found in Crawford’s own books. And that isn’t a criticism. One can certainly hope that if folks like Crawford keep beating this drum, some sizable good might come of it. (Frail hope, I cling to thee.) But ultimately the value is in the truth of it. Be thankful for those voices that speak it wherever you find them.

wholeness: elusive and ever present

Frederick Buechner, The Longing for Home, “The Journey Toward Wholeness”:

The world floods in on all of us. The world can be kind, and it can be cruel. It can be beautiful, and it can be appalling. It can give us good reason to hope and good reason to give up all hope. It can strengthen our faith in a loving God, and it can decimate our faith. In our lives in the world, the temptation is always to go where the world takes us, to drift with whatever current happens to be running strongest. When good things happen, we rise to heaven; when bad things happen, we descend to hell. When the world strikes out at us, we strike back, and when one way or another the world blesses us, our spirits soar. I know this to be true of no one as well as I know it to be true of myself. I know how just the weather can affect my whole state of mind for good or ill, how just getting stuck in a traffic jam can ruin an afternoon that in every other way is so beautiful that it dazzles the heart. We are in constant danger of being not actors in the drama of our own lives but reactors. The fragmentary nature of our experience shatters us into fragments. Instead of being whole, most of the time we are in pieces, and we see the world in pieces, full of darkness at one moment and full of light the next.

It is in Jesus, of course, and in the people whose lives have been deeply touched by Jesus, and in ourselves at those moments when we also are deeply touched by him, that we see another way of being human in this world, which is the way of wholeness. When we glimpse that wholeness in others, we recognize it immediately for what it is, and the reason we recognize it, I believe, is that no matter how much the world shatters us to pieces, we carry inside us a vision of wholeness that we sense is our true home and that beckons to us. It is part of what the book of Genesis means by saying that we are made in the image of God. It is part of what Saint Paul means by saying that the deepest undercurrent of all creation is the current that seeks to draw us toward what he calls mature humanhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ.

I picture Jesus at the Last Supper when he had every reason to understand that the end was upon him—not as an old crone in a dark little room saying good-bye to her grandson and his family but as a young man in a dark little room saying good-bye to life itself and everything he had lived for and was prepared to die for. I picture him looking around at the twelve friends and making an unforgettable utterance. “Peace I leave with you,” he says, when you would have thought he had no peace at all anywhere. “My peace I give to you; not as the world gives do I give to you. Let not your hearts be troubled, neither let them be afraid” (John 14:27).

The kind of peace that the world gives is the peace we experience when for a little time the world happens to be peaceful. It is a peace that lasts for only as long as the peaceful time lasts because as soon as the peaceful time ends, the peace ends with it. The peace that Jesus offers, on the other hand, has nothing to do with the things that are going on at the moment he offers it, which are for the most part tragic and terrible things. It is a peace beyond the reach of the tragic and terrible. It is a profound and inward peace that sees with unflinching clarity the tragic and terrible things that are happening and yet is not shattered by them. He loves his friends enough to be more concerned for their frightened and troubled hearts than he is for his own, and yet his love for his friends is no more where his peace comes from than his impending torture and death are where his peace will be destroyed. His peace comes not from the world but from something whole and holy within himself which sees the world also as whole and holy because deep beneath all the broken and unholy things that are happening in it even as he speaks, Jesus sees what he calls the Kingdom of God.

All his life long, wherever Jesus looked, he saw the world not in terms simply of its brokenness—a patchwork of light and dark calling forth in us now our light, now our dark—but in terms of the ultimate mystery of God’s presence buried in it like a treasure buried in a field. It is not just that the Kingdom is like a pearl of great price, like a mustard seed, like leaven. It is indeed like them in ways that Jesus suggests in his parables, but it is also within them as it is also within us. Pearls, seeds, fields, leaven, the human heart, all of them carry within them something of the holiness of their origin. It is the wholest and realest part of their reality and of ours. Sinners are made in the image of God no less than saints. Even a sparrow fallen dead by the roadside is transparent to holiness. To be whole, I believe, is to see the world like that. To see the world like that, as Jesus saw it, is to be whole. And sometimes I believe that even people like you and me see it like that. Sometimes even in the midst of our confused and broken relationships with ourselves, with each other, with God, we catch glimpses of that holiness and wholeness which, no matter how buried and unrecognized, are still part of who we are.

the measure of things

Matthew Giambrone:

We thought of measurement and its purpose the other day as we read that the tornado in Menasha, Wisconsin, was measured as an “EF-3” storm. It seems somehow a very tidy and comfortable designation for an event that caused such suffering and destruction; surely we should measure such an event on a more human scale. As it happens, however, that’s exactly what the EF scale does do.

As a scale for measuring tornadoes, the EF Scale runs from o to 5, and the designation means “Enhanced Fujita Scale.” The original Fujita Scale was developed by Tetsuya Theodore “Ted” Fujita, a University of Chicago meteorologist, precisely to designate tornadoes by the degree of damage they cause. His work in that and related areas were among the most important developments in the history of meteorology, the study and measurement of weather.

Fujita Tetsuya was born in Kitakyushu City, Japan, in 1920. He took his degree in mechanical engineering in 1943, and by the following year was an assistant professor of physics at the Meiji College of Technology. On August 9, 1945, an American plane was scheduled to drop the atomic bomb designated “Fat Man” on the Kokura railway, a few miles from Professor Fujita’s home, but because of cloudy weather it turned instead to Nagasaki. In the aftermath, the Japanese government asked Professor Fujita to investigate what had happened. By using the burn shadows on the insides of bamboo stakes used to place flowers in Nagasaki cemeteries, he was able to determine the location and height of the bomb at the moment of detonation.

[…]

An F-3 tornado, for instance, is characterized in the original scale by “roofs and some walls torn off well-constructed houses; trains over-turned; most trees in forests uprooted; heavy cars lifted off ground and thrown.” While we may tend to think of storms in terms of wind speed, the Fujita Scale, and its update, the Enhanced Fujita Scale, is still an estimate, and not a measurement, of wind speed, based on the observable effects of the wind, and not the other way around. It is the accounting of the damage, and not the damager, that forms the basis of the scale.

[…]

Professor Fujita’s work came at a time when great leaps in technology had become available for the observation and measurement of ordinary human life and the phenomena around us. Advances in satellite photography, radar observations, and airflight technology and instrumentation, had made the calculation of standardized measurements on a broad scale easier than had been previously imaginable. But consider this: It was not a radar map or super-anemometer that formed the idea of an EF-3. It was not the power of technological measurement and calculation alone that gave order and understanding to this aspect of our world, thereby sparing thousands of lives. It was the very human powers of a man’s well-trained mind and imagination.

As one of Professor Fujita’s colleagues explained after his death in 1998, “He had a way to beautifully organize observations that would speak the truth of the phenomenon he was studying.”

And that is perhaps the most human way of measuring things.

to fill with small kindnesses

Hearth & Field interview:*

H&F: … What are some practical things someone can do to make life lovelier?

Mrs. Elliott: A great place to start is with practical kindness — small kindnesses to your home, yourself, your family members, your community.

Because we all have things to do in life. You’ve got to do the dishes. You’ve got to do laundry. You’ve got to go to work. There’s no escape from these things, and there’s not supposed to be.

But maybe there is some little kindness you can do to make that work more beautiful in your life and the lives of others, to make things less utilitarian and highlight the reality that they are blessings. For example, maybe you don’t love your job at the moment, but you can still take the time to pack yourself a nice lunch so that you have something to look forward to at work. Grow a few of the ingredients or get them from the farmer’s market; introduce yourself to the farmer, and maybe some weekend drive out to his farm and get some milk. Or buy yourself a quarter of beef and a chest freezer and just enjoy that you have that really good meat waiting for you.

Now all of a sudden your normal work day has something in it to look forward to. You’ve been kind to yourself in that way.

Or at home, you can take the time to warm your mug for your coffee. And to sit still just for a minute in the morning as you wake up. Or you can change the sheets on the bed more often, or take steps to make sure that when you get out of the shower, you always have a clean, dry towel waiting for you. Or you can put your dish soap in a pretty pitcher and make an effort to notice how nice it is to pour the soap out onto a brand new sponge. Homemaking is full of opportunities for such small kindnesses to home, self, and family.

* “Shaye and Stuart Elliott live on a small homestead in Northern Central Washington, where, among other things, they run a cooking community and the “Homemaker Chic” podcast and direct their children’s homeschooling co-op. We recently sat down with the Elliotts to ask them about thrift, beauty, and provision in home life. What, we wondered, can families do to help themselves live a rich and beautiful life within the limits of their particular circumstances?”

Addition: See this post from Bethany H. on collecting matchbooks to replace bland clicky lighters.

political illusions

Something I’ve been thinking about, wanting to say more about, but setting aside for now.

James Davison Hunter (2010):

Most people assume that the state is subsumed by democracy; that it is the means by which democratic governance occurs. Yet for the better part of the last century, many of the most insightful political and social theorists—including Max Weber, Lewis Mumford, Robert Michels, Michel Crozier, Reinhard Bendix, and Jacques Ellul— have insisted that there is an important distinction between the two, that they are decoupled in important ways and, most importantly, the relationship between them is at odds.

… The state is a massive, relatively autonomous bureaucratic organization whose purpose is to administer innumerable discrete tasks that make the regime function. Decisions made are filtered through nu-merous, often-unrelated bureaus staffed by professionals who have their own autonomous (and nondemocratic) decision-making authority. The tasks the state undertakes may be influenced by ideals or values provided by the political class, but those tasks do not embody those ideals. Rather, the tasks that define the actions of the state are administrative in nature and the highest aim is always efficiency.

The importance of specialists in politics is not restricted to governance but it extends into the core rituals and practices of democratic processes—not least of which is the challenge of getting elected. Here too political experts are involved at every level shaping the terms by which candidates present themselves, the positions they take on issues, and so on.

There are two critical implications of this situation. The first is that the state is not subject to electoral will. What this means is that political participation—both for politicians and citizens—is less about the expression of their sovereignty over the state than it is a surrender of their will to various political experts and technicians and the rules they have established. As Jacques Ellul noted long ago, that submission may be accompanied by great devotion to the cause, great prestige from being part of a group, and a great mystique surrounding the personalities who lead, but these are mainly “bromides for the conscience” that distract one from the reality of how much authenticity and freedom of judgment one has actually lost in the bargain. He undoubtedly overstates the case, as he often did, but the contention is more correct than not. In the end, popular sovereignty means less than we might hope. In this light, democracy is led by the bureaucratic necessities of the state arguably even more than it leads and directs the state.

Jacques Ellul (1967):

Eventually, any democratic administration inevitably rediscovers the idea of administrative decentralization. Of course such “local freedoms” are desirable; in fact, local autonomy is essential. But, first of all, there is very little likelihood of true decentralization taking place; it runs counter to the entire course of our society, and there is not the slightest indication of a reversal in that respect. Above all, such decentralization could take effect only in local communities and departments. But these are only a secondary aspect of an administration. The great administrative forces such as finances, police, propaganda, and the administration of science and technology, cannot be truly decentralized. They demand a carefully worked-out national organization, not diverse centers free to make autonomous decisions. An economic plan can include the establishment of decentralized organs, but it does so only within a perfectly centralized framework. One cannot see, therefore, how there can be true decentralization if a local organ, except for certain details and relatively unimportant technical means, is held to do and execute what has been decided beforehand. Therefore the term “popular administration” or “democratic administration” is nothing but a hollow formula with only a purely emotional content.

The epigraph Ellul chose for that book, Political Illusions:

The people will fancy an appearance of freedom; illusion will be their native land.

— Saint-Just