by

you somehow

A mixed feelings post from two weeks ago that I wasn’t sure was worth the time. But whatever. I added a little memory to it and here it is.


“In case you somehow missed it…”

Thusly O. Alan Noble starts his piece on the Christianity Today (CT) kerfuffle that Ruth Graham reported on last week and that Bonnie Kristian, former deputy editor of CT, also wrote about.

I want to talk about those two little words, “you somehow.”

I am not as well-read as my reputation often suggests. Not even close, I would argue. For one thing, I am a slow reader; I can read at about the pace that I talk, and often read slower than that. And most the people who I read make me feel like I don’t read or have not read much at all, because, compared to them, I haven’t and don’t.

That said, I do read about… 100x more than almost everyone else I know. That’s probably not an exaggeration, and I’m not boasting. Quite the opposite: I kind of don’t like how much time I spend reading — how much time I waste reading — which really is, quite literally, abnormal. And again, I am a slooow readeeer.

But I do know that I read a lot more than the average person.

I say all that only to say this: I “somehow” missed it. I’m a NYT subscriber, I even follow Ruth Graham regularly, and Bonnie Kristian’s newsletter shows up in my inbox every week. And still I somehow missed it.

And if I missed it, it’s a safe bet — I’ve thrown a couple feelers out to confirm, but it’s still a bet — that no one I know knows about it. Nor — with due respect to those whose jobs and lives are directly affected — would any of them care about it.

I don’t do this that much, but I do it often enough to be a little self-conscious about it. To be honest, I don’t like using phrases like “everyone I know,” etc. But part of what I’m “about” in this here blogosphere is exactly that funny gap found in that opening line — the gap between words that get passed around between The People Who Pass Around Words and the average person who never reads them.

And so, this morning I found myself sitting by the wood fire, drinking coffee and once again asking, with this reverberating existential chuckle, Who are you guys writing for? Who do any of you think you are writing for?

I hope it doesn’t sound like I’m taking one little line too seriously. (Or one word, really: “in case you missed it” is a very different thing from “in case you somehow missed it.”) It’s possible to read that opening line very lightly, even with a little humor. It’s possible, too, that if you were reading Noble’s piece then there really is a better chance that you would already have been in the know. But in my stubborn and biased little world, I read it as a hint, and a remarkably relevant one.

While I am certainly being cynically critical here, I’m also genuinely trying to figure this out. When Noble and Kristian say we need “institutions” like CT, I want to trust them. But that’s a difficult trust to put shape to: I have spent 40 years living in and among deeply evangelical circles and I do not exaggerate when I say that I don’t know one person who reads Christianity Today. I would struggle to find even one person who has ever subscribed to them.

The best that I can say — and I do largely believe this — is that the function of an institution like CT (if it is, in fact, right to call it an institution; I’m not certain about that) is nonetheless significant regardless of my own ability to trace it. I can and should attempt to grant that.

One can imagine wonderful ways that thoughtful if little-known publishing, no matter how “big” the name, could contribute to a bigger picture, or, as Noble says, how an institutional platform like CT could serve as “an incubator for evangelical writers, thinkers, and ideas.” At the same time, if a magazine read by very few outside the publishing industry simply disappeared, one can imagine all the energy, money, and time that went into it rather naturally redirecting itself, hopefully to a place with both institutional and grass roots.

But no matter how much I want to trust the hoped-for role of a magazine like CT, the problem still remains (as the ongoing administrative/editorial shakeup shakeup itself seems to indicate, though nothing I’m saying here is dependent on their current troubles.) Noble says we need them, and maybe that’s true. But need is a strong word. I think we should want magazines like CT, and we can benefit greatly from them. What we do need, however, are better conversations about who institutions or magazines like CT are for at all.

Let me attempt to get at something in the background here, something far more significant than one casual blogger being petty about an opening line.

I recall the lead-up to the 2016 election. The major leadership among (mostly white*) evangelicals seemed, by my reading, consistently opposed to the notion that faithful Christian witness could coexist with support for Mr. Trump.

“I will vote — but not for either of these two wicked candidates,” preached John Piper.

“To be a faithful Christian and American, I’m going to find myself unable to vote for either of those two choices from the major political parties,” said Al Mohler, to applause in whatever room he was in, I might add.**

Most leaders were not necessarily that blunt, but by and large they agreed: better to lose an election than to lose your soul.

I think everyone knew or suspected that support for Trump among evangelicals was a gigantic elephant in the room — an elephant in the room that was about to start walking around get the zoomies. (Possibly a few felt the need to be so blunt because they saw this antsy elephant.) Still, generally speaking, the expectation was that Hillary Clinton would win; the vibe from those with a public, published voice was that we were ready to move on, shake it off, and get back to the roots of Christian witness.

Then it happened — the thing that evangelicals chose and that they have yet to, and may never, recover from.

“In light of this stunning outcome,” wrote Collin Hansen at The Gospel Coalition the day after the election,

we must admit the obvious division between many evangelical leaders, elected and self-appointed, and the rest of the movement. At some point in the primary I realized that whatever I might say about my concerns with Trump, most American evangelicals weren’t listening. The same was even true with much more popular, trusted, and wise thinkers.

Reeling from the results of that insane election, Hansen had a question that badly needed asking, and he asked it bluntly: “Who exactly, are we ‘leaders’ claiming to lead?”

Hansen is editor in chief at The Gospel Coalition and former associate editor at (you guessed it) Christianity Today.

I have never since that time had the impression that they had or even could answer that question.***

I haven’t grabbed it, but it’s possible that at some point I’ll read Bonnie Kristian’s book In Defense of Evangelicals. Though she’s been in the subscription inbox for some time, I don’t know Kristian’s writing very well. My sense is that she’s quite solid. And I’m remarkably happy that Alan Jacobs, who I’ve read a lot of, provides the foreword and praise for her book. Happier I could not be to see these two fine people going to bat for evangelicals. As a disgruntled but still deeply Christian “exvangelical” Gonzo, I have my doubts about the effectiveness. I have pretty clear memories of Sunday lunch conversations and my own evolution away from the merit of “evangelicalism,” or even of the word “evangelical” itself. But I maintain a fondness for that world and for those people that the criticism cannot contain or extinguish.

A lot of different things are true here at the same time!

____

*At the time, I took Thabiti Anyabwile as representative of the non-white evangelical vote: “Between Clinton and Trump, I’m voting Clinton. I’ll go back to not voting when this man is defeated!” Or: “Donald Trump is destroying a party and a church in one candidacy,” he wrote in July 2016. “Next: the entire country.”

I can’t be sure, but as far as I can tell, the pieces that Anyabwile wrote going into that election have been scrubbed from the Gospel Coalition website. Here’s an excerpt from one that previously appeared on the site on June 7, 2016:

Here’s the problem with living 50 years after the American Civil Rights Movement and the de jure segregation of the land that produced it: Too many people now have no idea how every-day-horrendous-and-perilous life was under that system. And if you can’t imagine the daily stresses and sudden endangerment faced by African Americans in that system, then chances are you can’t quite fathom the alarm that survivors or students of that period have when we look at a Mr. Trump. And failing to recognize these things, you may be vulnerable to sliding over to the Trump column without due consideration of the ugliness of racism.

**I’ve mentioned Al Mohler before. On the way to the 2016 election, few evangelical leaders, it seemed to me, were more straightforward and vocal about Christians, as he put it, “supporting the insupportable and defending the in defensible” by voting for Trump. But Mohler quickly went on to set a very bad example for the kids. In fact, few evangelical leaders, it seems to me, have more blatantly and vocally turned hypocritical tail. If CT does get right-wing TikTokified, I think he’ll fit right in.

***I’m refraining from the use of language, but there’s a good phrase that describes this “something is deeply wrong” shock and the subsequent condition we have.