by

the bread and the sentence, the office and the whip

Omar Mohammed:

People call them monsters. I will not. A monster is a creature without choice. To call these men and women monsters is to say they could not help what they did. That is a lie, and the lie serves them, because it removes the thing that makes their acts punishable: the choice.

I compiled intelligence files on thirty-eight of them. I will not publish their names. But I will describe how they lived inside the city they governed—because the living is where the truth sits. The killing is what the world already knows. The living is what the world refuses to see.

The shift change happened on Thursdays and Tuesdays. Each fighter received leave every fifteen days. Those who worked in the judiciary, the education bureau, and the real estate office kept regular hours. They ate at the restaurants on hagata Street—the cultural district, the street where the bookshops had been. The foreign fighters—Chechens, Tunisians, men from the Gulf—treated the restaurants as though they were on holiday. They had moved into the furnished houses of families given seventy-two hours to leave with nothing. A German fighter married a local girl and was living in the Andalus neighborhood, in a home of displaced Christians. He cooked in a kitchen that still smelled of the spices the Christian woman had stored in jars she had labeled in Syriac.

I knew one of them. Two doors from a friend’s house. He had been a taxi driver before the fall. After the fall, he appeared in uniform. He was responsible for interrogation. We still sat together sometimes in the evenings. He told me about the women they had killed. He used the word “cleaned.” Then he asked whether I had eaten, and whether my mother was well.

A livestock trader—forty-eight years old, two wives, nine children—was appointed judge in the Sharia court, sentencing former police officers to death. The distance between the courthouse where he sentenced men and the bakery where he bought bread for his children was four minutes by car.

A petty criminal—illiterate, accusations of violence—joined the intelligence service. He was given a weapon, a salary, and the authority to arrest and kill. The authority came with a title. The title came with a department. The department came with a filing system. The filing system made him legitimate. The machine did not ask who you had been. It asked who you were willing to become.

The Education Bureau was rewriting the curricula inside the central library of Mosul University—-headed by a German citizen of Egyptian origin from the al-Zarqawi network, a man known as Dhul-Qarnayn. By February 2015, the campus had become a military installation—residence halls housing fighters, laboratories converted to weapons workshops. The Sudair tourist village on the outskirts, where families had picnicked, became a training camp. The buildings were the same. The forest was the same. The picnic tables were still there. The weapons were new.

That distance—four minutes, the same afternoon, the same man—is what the word “monster” conceals. Monsters do not buy bread. Monsters do not ask about school. These men did all of those things, on the same days, with the same hands.

I do not hate them. Hatred requires a reduction of the other person to a category, and the work I did for eighteen months was the refusal to reduce anything to a category. I documented them with the precision of a man who understood that the record is the only thing that survives the regime that produced it. Accuracy requires seeing them as what they were—the taxi drivers and seminary students and livestock traders and petty criminals who made choices, who had full control of their actions, who bought bread on the way home from the courthouse, and who will one day answer for what they did between the bread and the sentence.

[…]

One of these organizational charts was designed against a background of flowers. Pink and white blossoms, green grass, blue sky. Someone in the Islamic Police’s administrative office had chosen this template. Someone had selected the flowers. The same department that processed flogging sentences and tracked executions had decorated its personnel chart with wildflowers. I do not know what to do with that detail except to record it. The flowers are the thesis of this chapter compressed into a single image: the office and the whip, together, in the same document, produced by the same hand. The flowers and the death sentences. The blue sky and the inventory of weapons.

[…]

Not masked men in the desert. An office. Using the vocabulary of God. Staffed by the neighbors. Decorated with flowers. Stamped in blue ink on lined paper.